Our Menu
Appetizers / Starters
Chicken Wings
$14.99
FAT juicy lollipop wings, drums & flats, tossed with your choice of Mild or Hot Buffalo, BBQ, Teriyaki, Sweet chili, Boom Boom, Dry jerk rub, Garlic Parmesan, , Old Bay or "Hot & Crabby", served with celery | Add: Blue Cheese .50, Ranch .50 *Choose ALL Flats OR ALL Drums, Add $3
Seafood Skins
$11.99
Crisp potato skins stuffed with shrimp, scallops & bacon, topped with melted cheddar jack cheese, a sprinkle of Old Bay & served with sour cream & chives
Coconut Shrimp
$13.99
Large Gulf shrimp, dipped in a toasted coconut/panko mix and fried golden brown served with chili marmalade
Scampi Toast
$14.99
Jumbo Gulf shrimp sautéed in scampi sauce & served with garlic toast points
Hot Crab & Shrimp Dip
$14.99
A "boatload" of homemade dip topped with a dollop of guacamole and pico de gallo and served with our house made corn chips
Ahi Tuna
$15.99
Sushi grade Ahi Tuna with black and white toasted sesame seeds seared rare, sliced thin. Served on a bed of wakame salad with wasabi, pickled ginger and soy sauce
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
$16.99
Indescribably delicious, bacon wrapped jumbo Gulf shrimp baked then flash fried, basted with our special sweet chili honey sauce
Boom Boom Shrimp
$15.99
Crispy shrimp tossed in Boom Boom sauce
Buffalo Cauliflower
$9.99
Cauliflower florets hand breaded, flash fried & tossed in a mild buffalo sauce then served with a side of bleu cheese … something different AND delicious
Fresh Cut Calamari
$13.99
Tender calamari lightly dusted, flash fried & served with chorizo, banana peppers and a side of marinara or citrus lime aioli
Seafood Deviled Eggs
$7.99
Four deviled egg halves, stuffed with our crab & shrimp mixture, topped with a baby shrimp & sprinkled with Old Bay
Bucket of Ribs
$12.99
Our tender BBQ pork spare ribs, slow cooked in house
Dive Bar Nachos
$14.99
Our house made corn chips buried under black beans, melted cheddar/jack cheese and queso cheese with minced jalapenos, topped with guacamole, pico de gallo and sour cream | Add: Salsa $1, Fresh Jalapenos $1, Chicken $5, Ground Beef $6, Shrimp $6
Meatballs
$12.99
Three HUGE "Meat-A-Balls", swimming in Chef's homemade marinara & topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Conch Fritters
$14.99
Served with a Key West Aioli
Smoked Wahoo Fish Dip
$13.99
Served with sliced red onion and crackers
Buffalo Chicken Dip
$12.99
Served in a sourdough bread bowl with chips for dipping
Peel 'N Eat Shrimp
$13.99/+
Steamed and sprinkled with Old Bay, served hot with melted butter or cold with cocktail sauce | Half Pound $13.99 | Full Pound $25.99
Grouper Cheeks
$15.99
Grilled, blackened or fried served with tartar sauce
Stuffed Shrooms
$12.99
Mushroom caps stuffed with our seasoned seafood mixture & topped with our rich & creamy imperial sauce
Blackened Filet Tips
$15.99
Served with BBQ sauce
Mussels or Clams
$16.99
A heaping portion of mussels or littleneck clams, tossed in marinara sauce or white wine garlic butter, served with toast points. Served over Pasta add: $3
Baked Cauliflower "Flatbread of the Week"
$11.99
Ask your Server or Bartender for details…
Signature Entrées
FINS Signature Crab Cake Dinner
MP
A 6 1/2 oz extra large jumbo lump crab cake charbroiled to a golden brown, served with choice of sauce & choice of 2 sides
Baked Crab Imperial
MP
Jumbo lump crab meat topped with a rich & creamy imperial sauce, then browned to perfection and served with toast points & choice of side
Baked Stuffed Shrimp
$19.99
Four jumbo butterflied shrimp stuffed with our seasoned seafood mixture, then topped with a rich and creamy imperial sauce, served with choice of side
Stuffed Flounder (A B-more Fave!)
$21.99
Two flounder filets, stuffed with our seasoned seafood mixture, then topped with a rich and creamy imperial sauce, & baked to a golden brown, served with choice of side
Fresh Catch
MP
Choice of today's fresh catch fish served grilled, blackened, broiled or fried with choice of 2 sides Add: Our rich & creamy seafood Imperial $6
Taco Entree -Sauteed Shrimp, Fish or Boom Boom Shrimp
$16.99/+
Shrimp or fish, with confetti lettuce, purple cabbage, lime cilantro aioli & fresh mango salsa, OR … Crispy Boom Boom shrimp, with confetti lettuce and FINS mango pineapple jalapeno slaw. *Both served in choice of flour tortillas or lettuce wraps with a side of rice & beans | Shrimp or Cod $16.99 | Mahi $19.99 | Grouper MP
Creamy Seafood Pasta
$26.99
Sauteed shrimp, scallops and lobster tossed in our homemade lobster cream sauce and topped with parmesan cheese, tossed with penne pasta and served with toast points
Grilled Polynesian Shrimp Skewers
$20.99
Two grilled or blackened shrimp skewers, served over island rice with a Teriyaki glaze and a side of green beans
Diver Down Scallops
MP
Large Sea scallops lightly blackened & pan seared to perfection, served with island rice topped with mango salsa
Seafood Enchiladas
$19.99
Three grilled tortillas, filled with cheese, Gulf shrimp & scallops, smothered in our cream sauce and baked to perfection, then topped with a dollop of Pico de Gallo and served with your choice of side
Key West Cheesy Alfredo Tortellini
$23.99
Cheese tortellini served with Chef's special Key West lime infused alfredo sauce with shrimp, lobster, parmesan and garnished with scallions, served with toast points
Seafood Paella
$22.99
Our version of the classic: Gulf shrimp, littleneck clams, mussels & Spanish chorizo, tossed with olive oil and island rice, served with toast points
Classic Shrimp Scampi
$21.99
Gulf shrimp sautéed in a white wine garlic butter sauce, topped with parmesan, served over pasta with toast points
Sizzling Fajitas
$21.99
Your choice of protein, served over quick-seared peppers & onions with sides of sour cream, Pico de Gallo, cheddar/jack cheese, guacamole and 3 tortillas, served with island rice and black beans | Protein choices: Chicken, Steak $23.99, Shrimp & Scallops $24.99 | Add an extra protein for $8
Rib Dinner
$18.99/+
Our tender BBQ pork spare ribs, cooked in house & served with your choice of side | Half Rack $18.99 | Full Rack $32.99
Fettuccine Alfredo
$19.99
Served in a classic creamy Alfredo sauce with toast points $19.99 Add Chicken $21.99 Add Shrimp $23.99 Add Blackened Filet Tips $23.99
12oz NY Strip Steak
$29.99
Grilled to your liking, served with mashed potatoes & grilled asparagus
Soups & Salads
Lobster Bisque
$4.99/+
A creamy & flavorful bisque with bites of lobster, served with oyster crackers | Choose: Crock $9.99 (Sub a Sourdough Bread Bowl Add $2) | Cup $4.99
Island Cobb
$15.99
Fresh spring mix with avocado, heirloom tomatoes, cucumbers, hard boiled egg, bleu cheese crumbles and apple wood smoked bacon served with our southern louie dressing on the side | Add: Chicken $5, Shrimp $6, Ahi Tuna $6, Fresh Catch – Market Price
Sunshine Citrus
$15.99
A little bit of Florida in every bite. Fresh spring mix topped with strawberries, orange slices, blueberries, raspberries, heirloom tomatoes, candied pecans and goat cheese. Served with apple cider vinaigrette on the side | Add: Chicken $5, Shrimp $6, Ahi Tuna $6, Fresh Catch – Market Price
FINS Caesar
$12.99
Chopped romaine lettuce tossed in a creamy Caesar dressing with parmesan cheese and herb croutons | Add: Chicken $5, Shrimp $6, Ahi Tuna $6, Fresh Catch – Market Price
Grilled Romaine
$12.99
Served with goat cheese, candied pecans, bacon bits and a Balsamic Vinaigrette drizzle | Add: Chicken $5, Shrimp $6, Ahi Tuna $6, Fresh Catch - Market Price
Sandwiches & Wraps
All Sandwiches served with choice of Side | Gluten Free Bun available $2.99
Coconut Shrimp Wrap
$15.99
Chopped coconut shrimp, confetti lettuce, tomatoes, mango salsa and chili marmalade, wrapped then pressed in a grilled tortilla
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$15.99
Fresh marinated chicken breast fried and served on a crunchy ciabatta roll, with lettuce and tomato … OR … Get it Buffalo style with carmelized onions & bleu cheese crumbles!
Filet-O-Fins Sandwich
MP
Fresh catch, grilled, blackened or fried golden brown, topped with lettuce, tomato and crispy onion straws, served on a sweet toasted brioche bun with your choice of sauce on the side
Philly Cheesesteak
$16.99
A mound of thinly sliced ribeye topped with sautéed onions, bell peppers & smoked provolone served on an authentic toasted Philly roll
Bimini Wrap
$14.99
Blackened grilled chicken OR shrimp (Add: $1), topped with mozzarella cheese, confetti lettuce, pico de gallo & ranch dressing, wrapped then pressed in a grilled tortilla
Blackened Shrimp BLT&A Wrap
$15.99
Blackened shrimp, bacon, lettuce, tomato and avocado with our southern Louie sauce
Cape Cod Reuben
$14.99
Fried haddock, swiss cheese and cole slaw drizzled with 1,000 island dressing and served on a sweet toasted brioche bun
The ULTIMATE BLT
$14.99
Thick sliced bacon, tomato and spring mix, with bacon aioli on one side and tomato "jam" on the other, served on a crunchy ciabatta roll OR wrapped & pressed in a grilled tortilla
Fried Flounder Sandwich
$14.99
A fried flounder fillet, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, dill pickle slices & tartar, served on a sweet brioche bun | Add extra flounder fillet $4
Soft Shell Crab Sandwich
$15.99
Lettuce, tomato, remoulade and an Old Bay sprinkle served on a toasted Philly roll
Blackened Chicken OR Shrimp Bayou Wrap
$14.99
Served with lettuce, tomato, fried onion straws and remoulade sauce | Shrimp $1
Crab Cake Sandwich
A 6 1/2 oz extra large jumbo lump crab cake charbroiled to a golden brown, served with lettuce & tomato on a sweet toasted brioche bun with your choice of sauce
Burgers
(Are you feeling "Clucky"? Try a Chicken Breast instead!) All burgers are 8 oz Angus burgers grilled to order, served on a sweet toasted brioche bun with FF (With the exception of the Beyond Meat Burger!) Add: Bacon $2, Mushrooms $1 *Gluten Free Bun Available $2.99
Paradise Cheeseburger
$14.99
Choice of cheese served with lettuce, tomato and onion
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$15.99
Topped with mushrooms, carmelized onions, swiss cheese and "horsey" sauce
Black and Bleu Burger
$15.99
Sprinkled with blackening seasoning then topped with bacon, carmelized onions & bleu cheese crumbles
Bacon Jam Burger
$16.99
Topped with bacon, bacon jam, bacon aioli and cheddar cheese
The "Beyond Meat" Burger
$14.99
For our VEGAN friends … no animal products! Served with lettuce, tomato and onion on an oat bun with choice of side
FIN-tastic Baskets
FINS Famous Seafood Basket
$25.99
A heaping basket of Atlantic cod, shrimp & large Sea scallops, lightly dusted then fried and served over fries with tartar and cocktail sauces
The Best Fried Shrimp Ever
$21.99
Large shrimp lightly dusted then fried to a golden brown and served over fries with cocktail sauce
FINS Fish & Chips
$21.99
Fresh Atlantic cod dipped in a light beer batter and fried crunchy, then served over fries with tartar sauce
Sides
Mango Pineapple Jalapeno Slaw
$3.99
Black Beans & Island Rice
$3.99
Red Skin Mashed Potatoes
$3.99
Fries
$3.99
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.99
Fried Plantains
$4.99
Fresh Green Beans
$4.99
Fresh Grilled Asparagus
$4.99
Side Garden Salad or Side Caesar
$5.99
Desserts
FINS Signature Key Lime Pops
$9.99
Four mini key lime pops with graham cracker crust dipped in dark chocolate and topped with kiwi lime sauce and whipped cream
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
$9.99
Moist buttery cake and a scoop of vanilla ice cream, topped with gooey cane sugar sauce
Caramel Sea Salt Cheesecake
$9.99
NY style cheesecake, swirled with caramel, dusted with sea salt and drizzled with caramel sauce
Reese's Peanut Butter Pie
$9.99
Rich chocolate cookie crust, with a light & creamy filling of REESE'S creamy peanut butter, topped with chunks of REESE'S Peanut Butter Cups & Hersheys Dark Fudge and Hersheys Caramel
Kid's Menu
Served with FF or Fruit, a Kid's Soda or Iced Tea and a FINS Frisbee!
Mini Cheeseburgers
$7.99
2 Mini Cheeseburgers on brioche buns
Grilled Cheese
$7.99
Grilled sandwich on a brioche bun with choice of cheese
Fish & Chips
$8.99
Lil FINS portion of our battered fish
Fried Shrimp
$8.99
Large Gulf shrimp fried or grilled
Mini Corndogs
$7.99
Deep fried...just like at the Carnival
Chicken Tenders
$7.99
Homemade fried chicken tenders w/sauce choice
Mac & Cheese
$7.99
A crock of cheesy yumminess
Lil' Nachos
$7.99
Tortilla chips topped with queso and shredded cheddar